For a lot of South African candidates, this question causes a visible pause. Not because they don't have an answer — because the question itself doesn't quite translate.
Why This Question Confuses SA Candidates
In many South African workplaces, hierarchy is respected in a fairly direct way. Questioning a manager's decision, pushing back on a deadline, or proactively telling your boss they're wrong about something can read as overstepping — even if you're right. Deference to authority is often built into the culture of professionalism itself.
In the US, it's the opposite. "Managing up" isn't seen as insubordination — it's seen as a core administrative skill. US employers want to know that you can tactfully manage your manager's time, priorities, and blind spots, not just execute their instructions.
So when a South African candidate hears "tell me about a time you managed up," the instinct is often to either:
Freeze, because they've never framed their work that way, or
Give an example that's actually about following instructions well — which misses the point entirely.
What "Managing Up" Actually Means to a US Interviewer
It's not about disagreement for its own sake. It means:
Protecting your manager's time and priorities, even from your manager themselves — like flagging when they've overcommitted to meetings, or pointing out a scheduling conflict before it becomes a problem.
Speaking up when you see a mistake, tactfully — catching a wrong date on a travel booking, or noticing a report is going out with outdated numbers.
Anticipating needs before being asked — having the flight confirmation ready before your manager remembers to ask for it.
Giving respectful pushback — "I noticed this meeting overlaps with the board call — should I move one of them?" instead of silently double-booking and hoping it works out.
None of this requires confrontation. It requires initiative and tact — which, if you think about it, South African admin professionals often already do instinctively. The gap usually isn't the skill. It's not recognizing it as something worth naming out loud.
How to Actually Answer This Question
Use a simple structure: Situation → Action → Result.
Weak answer (too passive):
"My manager asked me to book travel and I did it quickly and accurately."
This describes following instructions well, not managing up. It won't land.
Strong answer:
"My manager had back-to-back meetings scheduled with only 5 minutes between them, including one requiring prep time she hadn't planned for. I flagged it, suggested moving a lower-priority meeting, and built in a 15-minute buffer before the one that needed prep. She said afterward it was the first day that week she didn't feel rushed."
Notice what this does: it shows you noticed something your manager didn't, took initiative without waiting to be asked, and the result improved things for them — not just for you.
Finding Your Own Example
If you're preparing for interviews, look back for moments like:
A time you caught an error before it reached your manager or their boss
A time you suggested a better way to structure their week or a recurring task
A time you had to tell your manager something they didn't want to hear (a deadline wasn't realistic, a request conflicted with another commitment) and handled it diplomatically
A time you prepared something before being asked, because you anticipated the need
You likely have more of these than you think — the work is just in reframing them, not manufacturing new ones.
The Bigger Cultural Shift This Question Reveals
This single interview question is really testing something broader: whether you see yourself as a passive executor of instructions, or an active partner in your manager's success. US workplaces — especially at the admin and EA level — reward the second framing heavily, even from junior staff. You don't need to become someone you're not to answer this well. You just need to recognize that the initiative and judgment you've probably already shown is exactly what they're asking about — it just goes by a different name here.
Weekly newsletter
Get the latest blog updates, practical hiring insights, and featured reads delivered straight to your inbox.
Read about our Privacy Policy.